How To . . . Make Your Own Pie Crust Shield


Getting ready to bake a ton of pies for Thanksgiving? Tired of burnt edges to your pie crusts, but don’t want to spend major $$ to buy commercial pie crust shields? Frustrated with trying to arrange foil strips and then nursing burnt fingers when the strips fall off in the oven?

Making your own pie crust shield is super easy, cheap, and will keep your fingers blister-free. And you won’t be tempted to curse in frustration at foil strips that just don’t stay put. Oh- and you will end up with perfectly browned pie crusts.

111010 073-1

To make you own pie crust shield you need the following: aluminum foil, scissors, pencil and the pie plate you will be baking in.

Set your pie plate, right side up, on a square of foil that is 2-3” larger than your pie plate.

060610 002-1

Trace the bottom of your pie plate (the smaller side).

060610 003-1

Set pie plate aside and cut out the inner circle.

060610 005-1

You can trim the corners on the outside edge, but I usually just leave them. Fill your pie crust, then set foil ring over the edge of the unbaked pie. Gently fold down outer edges, being careful not to squish all of that edge-crimping you worked so hard on!

111010 068-1


Bake pie, or quiche, with the pie shield on. Five minutes before the end of the cooking time, carefully remove shield. If the edges are not brown enough, leave shield off and bake until edges are golden brown. If the edges are browned, replace shield and continue cooking until quiche/pie is cooked through.

111010 073-1


Uses for Pie Crust Shield:



Filed under Breakfast/Brunch, Desserts, Tips and Tutorials

7 responses to “How To . . . Make Your Own Pie Crust Shield

  1. aveena

    This is super helpful! Thank you!


  2. Pingback: A Quick Guide to Making the Perfect Pie Crust and 6 Easy Recipes – The EatSmart Blog

  3. Pingback: 10 Don't-Bother-Buying Kitchen Tools | Managed WordPress Site

  4. Pingback: New Old-Fashioned Pumpkin Pie - Camille Watson

  5. Karen

    This is a great idea! I want to know how you cut out the circle so nice and neat. Mine doesn’t look like that and the foil is crinkled in general. LOL! I’m sure it will still work fine. Thanks!


  6. Pingback: DiscoverNet | Mistakes You’re Making When Cooking Pies

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s